A: You're not alone. Many New Jersey homeowners have seen their premiums jump 50% to 100% over the last few years, even with zero claims on their record. Insurers are raising rates due to broader market conditions, not just individual risk. The biggest reasons are:
-
Severe weather losses: Hurricanes, coastal flooding, wind damage and heavy rain events Insurance companies spread those costs across all policyholders.
-
Higher rebuilding costs: Labor and material costs have risen substantially since 2020. If your home were destroyed, it would cost much more to rebuild today.
-
Higher home values and replacement costs: Insurers periodically increase the dwelling coverage amount on your policy, which raises premiums.
Older homes in Haddonfield, Haddon Heights, Collingswood, and parts of Haddon Township are often viewed as higher insurance risks than newer homes in Cherry Hill or Voorhees. The reason isn't usually the age itself. It's the systems and construction behind the walls. Insurers pay close attention to roof age: A 20+ year-old roof can trigger significant premium increases or even underwriting issues. Electrical systems: Knob-and-tube wiring, older fuse boxes, Federal Pacific panels, and outdated electrical systems are viewed as higher fire risks. Plumbing: Galvanized steel, cast iron, and older water supply lines can increase the likelihood of water damage claims. Heating systems: Older boilers, furnaces, and oil tanks can raise concerns. Tree exposure: Many neighborhoods in Haddonfield and Haddon Heights have mature trees that contribute to wind and storm claims.
I had the same problem, and I’ll tell you how I solved it. My mortgage lender notified me that my insurance was going to double. So, they recommended a company called Matic.com. They shopped around for me and found a new company that was half of what my current insurer had quoted me. I was so happy with the result, I had them quote my auto insurance and it was cheaper with my new homeowners’ company, so I bundled and saved even more.